East Rochester Assessor's Office
120 West Commercial Street
East Rochester, New York 14445 ~ (585) 381-5151

Nicholas Morabito, III
Assessor

Additional Information on Assessment

Equity is the goal of the East Rochester Assessor's office. Under New York State Law, East Rochester is required to maintain an equal assessment value to market value ratio. In other words, the Assessor's Office must assess property based on its likely sale price. This is the fairest, most equitable method of property assessing, and East Rochester is one of many towns in Monroe County, including Pittsford, Chili, Parma, and Perinton, who seek to assess annually based on the housing market.

Why participate in the annual assessment program? Assessing property based on its market value makes sense and it's easy to understand a full value system instead of a fractional value system. By keeping assessments in line with market value, all taxpayers pay their fair share of taxes.

Does East Rochester complete a town wide reassessment every year? No. A town wide reassessment will only occur when village wide assessment values fall below 100% of market value as determined by the NYS Office of Real Property Services.

What is reviewed each year? Each year the Assessor reviews individual sales, new construction or demolition, and changes of use or occupancy.

What is market value? Market value is how much a property would sell for under normal conditions. Establishing market value depends on a buyer and seller each acting prudently and knowledgeably, that the property has been on the market for a reasonable amount of time, and that the price is unaffected by special financing or sales concessions like a "family sale" at a reduced selling price. 

Residential Market Value is based on the sale price of similar properties. Market adjustments are made for prominent physical characteristics like location, condition, size, number of bathrooms, fireplace, air conditioning, garage, decks, porches, etc.

Commercial Market Value is based on its potential to produce rental income. Potential gross income is determined and corresponding expenses are analyzed to arrive at a net operating income.

Complex Commercial & Industrial Market Value is based on the most appropriate valuation method for the property in question - cost method, market value, income based - or a combination of all three.

How is market value determined? Market value is determined by analyzing valid arms length real estate sales. The assessor does not set market value. The primary factor in establishing market value is the price paid for a neighboring home; other factors include affordability, condition and amenities of the property, interest rates, availability of amenities and jobs, and commuting distance.

When is my assessment effective each year? Each year the final assessment roll is sent to New York State and is effective July 1st. This final roll impacts your taxes in the following way - School District tax as of September 1st of the current year, County tax as of January 1st of the following year, and finally Town/Village tax as of June 1st of the following year.

Who do I talk with if I disagree with my assessment? The Assessor and his staff are available each year April 15th through May 1st to conduct an Informal Review with a property owner. These informal meetings provide property owners with an opportunity to produce evidence contradicting the assessed valuation of a property. You may also file for a hearing with the Board of Assessment Review if no agreement was reached during your informal review meeting. The Board of Assessment review meets the first Tuesday in June each year.

Tell me more about the Board of Assessment Review - BAR and my hearing with them ? Your written application should include statements, records, and other relevant information to support your complaint. You have the right to attend the hearing of the BAR and to present statements supporting your complaint. You may appear in person, with or without an attorney or other representative. You may also submit your complaint in writing only. The BAR consists of 3 members appointed by the Village Board. The BAR cannot include the Assessor or any member of the assessor's staff. The Assessor is required, by law, to attend all formal hearings of the BAR and has the right to be heard on any complaint.

Who oversees the assessor's office? The East Rochester Assessor's Office is overseen by the New York State Office of Real Property Services, not the local taxing jurisdictions affected by the Assessor's office - namely the local school district, county legislature or town board.

What do I bring to my informal review or Board of Assessment Review appointment? You must provide documentation which states current market value; acceptable forms include:

  • the purchase price if purchased in the last 3 years
  • offering price if up for sale in the last 3 year
  • recent sale price of comparable properties
  • a recent appraisal performed by a NYS Certified Appraiser as of the assessment valuation date specified by law
  • rental information if currently rented, or 
  • income/expense data for the past 3 years if commercial or industrial property

Want more information? Visit the New York State Office of Real Property Services Web-Site at: www.orps.state.ny.us